Table of Contents
As your Flutter app grows in complexity, managing state across screens can quickly get chaotic. That’s why choosing the right state management approach is key for complex Flutter apps.
In this guide, we’ll compare the popular options for managing state in Flutter including setState, BLoC, Redux, MobX, and GetX. By the end, you’ll know how to choose the best Flutter state management for your next app.
- The downsides of relying solely on setState()
- How BLoC improves scalability
- Redux principles and Flutter implementation
- Simpler state management with MobX
- GetX as a lightweight reactive option
- Key factors to choose the best approach
- And more…
Let’s get started!
The Pitfalls of setState() Alone
By default, Flutter uses setState() for basic state management. It works great for simple apps.
But as your app grows, managing all state with setState() leads to:
- Hard to maintain complex state logic across widgets
- State scattered across widget tree
- Lots of wasted rebuilds from local state changes
- Spaghetti code that’s tough to scale
Relying solely on setState() for large apps gets messy fast. That’s where dedicated state management solutions come in.
BLoC – Flutter’s Default State Management Library
The BLoC pattern (Business Logic Component) is Flutter’s official state management solution. It improves over raw setState() with:
1. Separation of Concerns
BLoC separates your business logic from the UI layer. State logic moves from widgets into BLoCs. This simplifies widgets.
2. Granular State Updates
BLoC only triggers rebuilds for widgets that depend on a state change instead of everything. This minimizes wasted rebuilds.
3. Improved Predictability
State changes follow a predictable pattern via streams. And BLoCs are testable independent of UI.
BLoCs abstract state management into a logical, scalable pattern. This keeps apps maintainable as they grow.
Overall, BLoC is a big improvement for larger Flutter apps. It has a steeper learning curve, but ends up saving time as complexity increases.
Redux – Predictable Unidirectional Data Flow
Redux is another popular state management library for Flutter inspired by React. It enforces:
1. Single source of truth – State is stored in one central immutable store.
2. Unidirectional data flow – State only changes via dispatched actions.
3. Changes are predictable – Reducers handle state changes via pure functions.
This strict structure prevents bugs and makes state predictable.
Redux requires more boilerplate code but the unidirectional data flow is easy to trace. This helps debugComplex apps.
For basic apps, Redux is overkill. But it shines in large apps with lots of moving state.
MobX – Simple, Automatic Reactive State Management
MobX simplifies state management using reactive programming. State is wrapped in observables that automatically update any dependent components.
Key advantages of MobX:
- Less boilerplate – No need for action/reducer classes. Just use observables.
- Automatic tracking – Reactions handle propagating state changes.
- Simple debugging – Follow observable data flows visually.
- Lightweight – Smaller API footprint than Redux/BLoC.
For less complex apps, MobX provides easy state management without the boilerplate.
GetX – A High-Performance, Extra-Light Option
GetX combines state management, routing, and dependency injection in a lightweight package.
- Blazing fast performance – Intelligent state management using GetX controllers
- Minimal syntax – Much less boilerplate vs Redux/BLoC
- Easy state access – GetX makes state available app-wide
- Built-in route management – Transition between screens without context
For medium complexity apps, GetX provides high-performance state management with minimal code. Great for rapid development.
Which State Management Approach is Best for Your Flutter App?
Now that you know the top options, how do you choose? Consider these key factors:
1. App Complexity
If you’re building a simple app, stick with setState(). As your app grows, introduce BLoC or Redux to scale state management.
2. Your Team’s Existing Experience
If your team is already using BLoC or Redux in production, it makes sense to continue. Don’t introduce new libraries unnecessarily.
3. Boilerplate vs Simplicity Tradeoff
BLoC and Redux require more code but add predictability. MobX and GetX trade more boilerplate for simplicity and speed.
4. Performance Needs
If you need max performance for animations etc., GetX is likely the best choice.
5. Development Time
Redux, BLoC and MobX have longer learning curves. GetX has the fastest time to being productive.
There’s no universally best option. Choose based on your app’s unique complexity, team skills, performance needs and development timeline.
The key is using some form of centralized state management once you move past basic complexity. Don’t stick with just setState()!
Start Managing Flutter State Like a Pro
Evolving from setState() is crucial as your app grows. Use this guide to choose the best Flutter state management approach for YOUR app’s specific needs.
Whichever option you pick, your codebase will be much cleaner, scalable and bug-free by leveraging these battle-tested state management solutions.
Now you’re ready to build complex Flutter apps like a pro by expertly managing state with BLoC, Redux, MobX or GetX. Go unleash your productivity and take your app to the next level!